On the fateful day of May 11, 1999, Amy Fisher emerged from the confines of an upstate New York prison, embarking on a journey homeward via a chartered plane. Known to the public as the "Long Island Lolita," Fisher had once seized the headlines in 1992 for her role in a sensational love triangle involving a mechanic and his unsuspecting wife.
At the age of 24, Fisher, infamous for her gun-toting escapades and the reckless assault that had shaken the nation, was granted an early release on May 10, 1999. Remarkably, her newfound freedom owed itself to an unexpected source – the very woman she had nearly claimed the life of: Mary Jo Buttafuoco.
Back in 1992, when Buttafuoco was just 37 years old, Fisher discharged a .25-caliber bullet into her head near the entrance of the Massapequa, New York home she shared with her husband, Joey, the robust proprietor of a local auto-body repair shop.
The twist in the narrative unfolded seven years later during an April 1999 resentencing hearing, prompted by a court's acknowledgment that Fisher had not received fair representation from her initial lawyer during the 1992 trial.
In a surprising turn of events, Buttafuoco, an Irish Catholic mother of two, stepped forward to testify on Fisher's behalf, urging State Supreme Court judge Ira Wexner to show mercy to the once-obsessed teenager. With heartfelt sincerity, Buttafuoco conveyed, "She has shown true remorse and sorrow for what she did to me."
Directly addressing Fisher in the courtroom, Buttafuoco extended a plea, saying, "You are being given a second chance in life, and I pray you will take it and make something positive out of all this tragedy." Fisher, in a moment of contrition, admitted, "What happened to you... it wasn’t your husband’s fault… It was my fault, and I’m sorry."
In a poignant scene, the two women clasped hands in a courtroom that had fallen silent. Judge Wexner, acknowledging the gravity of the situation, vacated Fisher's 1992 guilty plea to reckless assault, a charge that initially carried a 5-to-15-year sentence. Thus, the next chapter in Amy Fisher's tumultuous life unfolded, marked by redemption, forgiveness, and the hope for a positive future.
In public statements, Mary Jo explained her stance on the matter, emphasizing the need for punishment for Amy Fisher's attempt on her life. She clarified that Fisher should not be labeled a 'Lolita,' but rather recognized as a troubled individual rather than a seductress. Surprisingly, a key factor in the case's merciful turn was the correspondence that had developed between the victim and Fisher's mother, Roseann, two years prior.
The heartfelt apology Fisher extended during the court proceedings led to her parole from the Albion Correctional Facility a few weeks later. The scandal had implicated not only Fisher but also Joey Buttafuoco, who had earlier received a six-month jail sentence for statutory rape due to their affair commencing when Fisher was just 16.
Fisher's release marked the end of the initial chapter of a saga that had commenced with a gunshot fired in a jealous rage on May 19, 1992. The case had reverberated globally, inspiring three made-for-TV movies, including portrayals by Drew Barrymoreand Alyssa Milano.
Now at the age of 44, Fisher, a divorced mother of three, returned to New York a couple of years ago after an attempt at a fresh start in Florida proved challenging due to persistent notoriety. Her children faced social isolation, burdened by the stigma associated with their mother.
Following Fisher's release, the Buttafuocos relocated to the West Coast, eventually divorcing in 2003. Joey Buttafuoco, attempting to leverage his notoriety into a Hollywood career, faced legal troubles and remarried in 2005 to Evanka Franjko.
Fisher chose to stay on Long Island, contributing newspaper columns for the Long Island Press and co-authoring a book, "If I Knew Then…," with the paper's editor. While the Buttafuocos settled in California, Fisher married Lou Bellera, a former NYPD cop. Allegations arose that Bellera guided her towards a career in the sex industry, which he denied. Cosmetic procedures, including breast augmentation, ensued, and Fisher's life took a turn into the adult entertainment industry.
Throughout the years, Fisher, Joey, and Mary Jo participated in various media engagements, including a 2006 TV reunion that culminated in an on-camera embrace between the two women. Fisher's life also intersected with reality TV, featuring in "Celebrity Rehab with Dr. Drew." Notably, a 2007 dinner on Long Island between Fisher and Joey Buttafuoco sparked rumors of a potential reality show.
By 2008, Fisher's marriage to Bellera had ended in divorce. Meanwhile, Mary Jo Buttafuoco published a book in 2009, titled "Getting It Through My Thick Skull," offering insights into the shooting and her relationship with her ex-husband. Describing him as a "sociopath," the book delved into the intricacies of their tumultuous connection.
In 2012, Mary Jo remarried Stu Tendler, who unfortunately passed away from cancer the previous year. Despite living with the remnants of Fisher's bullet and its ongoing effects, Mary Jo has emerged as an advocate for people with facial paralysis.
Reflecting on her experiences, Mary Jo admitted to thinking about Fisher frequently, especially when confronted with the daily challenges of living with facial paralysis. The impact of that fateful day continues to shape Mary Jo's life, as she perseveres as a vocal advocate and survivor.
See Also: